Employer has £100 to pay on wages.
New Secondary NIC rate = 13.8% + 1.25% = 15.05%. So the max. gross wage he can pay out = £100 ÷ 1.1505 = £86.92
New Primary NIC rate = 12% + 1.25% = 13.25%, add on official basic rate of tax 20% = 33.25%.
£86.92 less 33.25% = £58.02, an overall tax bill of £42 = 42%.
If you factor in VAT, which takes one-sixth of earnings in the productive economy, it's closer to 52% overall. It's far worse if you also have Student Loan Repayments or Working Tax Credits that are being clawed back.
Wednesday, 8 September 2021
Welcome to the new basic rate of tax - it's 42%
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
11:39
38
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Maths, National Insurance
Wednesday, 19 September 2018
Outbreak of common sense in Wales!
Emailed in by John D, from the BBC:
Wales should slash income tax rates to the lowest in the UK, according to one of the candidates challenging Leanne Wood for the Plaid Cymru leadership.
Adam Price said the basic, higher and additional rates could be cut by 9p and business rates and council tax ditched*. New land value taxes on residential, commercial and industrial residential land would fund the changes**, he said...
The Welsh Government is getting more tax powers next April, including partial control of income tax...
In proposals published on Friday, Mr Price said "introducing a National Land Value Tax on residential, commercial and industrial land (agricultural land would be excluded) could generate £6bn at a 3% rate on current values. This would enable us to abolish business rates, council taxes and lower income tax, at the basic, higher and additional rates, by 10p," he said.***
* His proposals don't mention ditching Land Transactions Tax as well, unfortunately.
** On a political level, it is better to say the Land Value Tax would fund those public services which increase land values, which is the fair way to fund them and which in turn would enable income tax to be reduced.
*** Something has got lost in translation here. Rhys ap Gwilym's original proposal worked on the basis of total council tax, business rates and income tax (basic and higher rate) revenues in Wales at £4 bn a year, so the LVT revenues required to replace council tax and business rates, and reduce income tax by 10% would be less than £4 bn, not £6 bn.
------------------------
Sobers of course runs with the messed up numbers in the comments, knowing full well that they are messed up. He also ignores the distinction between land value and total value including buildings.
Suffice to say, on a fiscally neutral swap, more than half of people would be better off, as wages are distributed more evenly than land ownership.
Total required revenues from LVT on housing (assuming revenues from LVT on commercial = same as revenues from Business Rates) = £2.7 bn.
£2.7 bn divided by 1.34 million households/homes is average £2,000 per household/home (up from current average just under £1,000), not Sober's wild overestimate of average £4,100 per household/home. So all tenants end up better off; a single earner who owns an average value home earning £22,000 or more; or a two-earner couple which owns an average value home earning £17,000 or more each.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
14:03
15
comments
Labels: Andy Price, Income Tax, Land Value Tax, Plaid Cymru, Wales
Tuesday, 3 July 2018
My marginal tax rate
For every £100 + VAT my employer invoices clients for work I have done, they pay me about £40 gross.
This nets down to £23 after income tax and NIC at my marginal rate (the overall average is a bit lower than that).
My wife decides how I spend two-thirds of my income. This is mainly private school fees for her social status reasons, officially known as "I just want what's best for the children", but either way it is rent, ransom or tax.
This leaves yours truly with £8 pocket money to spend on the finer things in life, out of the £120 that the client originaly paid, a marginal tax rate of 93% or so.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
07:31
4
comments
Labels: Income Tax
Tuesday, 17 April 2018
Most employees pay far more National Insurance than Income Tax
The 'earnings threshold' for NIC is lower than the personal allowance for income tax; and for basic rate taxpayers, total NIC is 25.8% of earnings above the threshold but income tax is only 20% of earnings above the personal allowance.
At the top of the basic rate band, it's £9,786 NIC and £6,900 income tax.
Above that, it flips over, NIC is 'only' 15.8% of earnings but income tax is 40%.
The break-even point at which you pay the same amount of NIC as you do income tax is about £58,300, which you can check here, so only the top few per cent of employees actually pay more income tax than they do NIC.
VAT raises approx. the same amount as National Insurance, meaning that a majority of employees probably pay more in VAT than they do in income tax as well.
Just sayin'.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
16:19
6
comments
Labels: Income Tax, National Insurance, VAT
Tuesday, 18 July 2017
Student fee and loan wibble.
From Fullfact.org:
"[The Labour] party’s education spokesman has admitted that the tuition fees policy has a £100 billion…She has admitted that there is a £100 billion black hole in Labour's student fees policy.”
Damian Green MP, 12 July 2017
Fullfact then explains that the net cost will be a lot lower than that, bearing in mind write offs and so on.
The point is surely that student loans are the worst of both worlds, they have the characteristics of loans and of a super-tax on income (9% of income over £21,000 p.a.). So writing them off or down is not an upfront 'cost' the government but a reduction in tax revenues.
The best way of looking at govt tax revenues is the annual amount. The best summary I have found is by the Institute for Fiscal Studies. Page 22 suggests that expected the extra revenues from the 9% surcharge will be about £6 billion a year, covering two-thirds of the £9.7 billion upfront cash cost of higher education. That's not nothing, but only about one per cent of UK govt revenues/spending.
Here comes the real wibble, and article by somebody from the (right wing/supposedly free market) Institute for Economic Affairs in City AM:
Moreover, deeply regressive policies are finding their way back to popular status, with very little push back. That Labour has been able to get away with linking the abolition of tuition fees to “fairness” is shameful; expecting workers on the minimum wage to subsidise students attending Oxbridge – whose career prospects are likely to earn them a much higher salary in the future – is anything but fair.
As our Lord and Saviour said on Twitter recently:

Education is A Good Thing (up to a point, I'm not talking about Mickey Mouse degrees) for the nation as a whole, so I've no objection to the taxpayer chipping in as that's the best way of ensuring that everybody has an equal-ish chance in life. It's like a non-cash citizen's dividend. We'd expect those that go to uni to end up earning more than they otherwise, that's sort of the whole point isn't it?
For sure, the 7% of kids who went to private school have a better chance of going to uni, but is that really so unfair? Their parents have waived a state education place (cost to the taxpayer approx. £70,000 per child) and they have pissed well over £100,000 up the private school wall, most of that goes to teachers or suppliers, so that generates a minimum of £40,000 in tax revenues per child (PAYE, irrecoverable VAT, corporation tax on suppiers etc), more than enough to cover the cost of a normal three year degree of £35,000-ish.
The only reason for tuition fees is that government spending on higher education has remained constant but student numbers have doubled. If we halved them again and kept net spending constant, we wouldn't need tuition fees. If student numbers were slimmed down to a sensible level, say 25% of school leavers, and all private school kids went to uni, that still means that one-in-five state schools kids would get to go to uni "for free" on top of the "free" state education they have already enjoyed [sic].
If their is any "unfairness", it is that a lot of the 'professions' are really just leeching off the fact that the government lays down stupid and complicated rules which the layman can't fathom. So we have lawyers (if judges weren't so useless, we wouldn't need barristers on £5,000 a day to explain things to them), auditors etc. What they earn is just rent, it is an appropriation of other people's earnings or wealth without adding to it.
And as it happens, most people in these 'professions' went to uni and have a very middle class background. I'd be all in favour of stemming this flow of rent by radically simplifying the rules, having judges who apply common sense and abolishing the audit requirement. Or imposing price caps on them. Or failing that, subjecting their income to a higher tax rate. In an ideal world there's be a flat income tax of no more than 20%, but a higher rate of 50% for the 'professions' seems fair and reasonable to me.
That levels out the only real unfairness that I can see - that some high earners didn't go to uni, or did but do something useful and made their way in the productive economy. So a tax on the 'professions' would be a much more sophisticated version of the graduate tax.
And with a Citizen's Income system, student maintenance grants/loans would not be an issue, of course students would get it.
Sorted.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
21:40
10
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Students
Tuesday, 16 June 2015
Rent = privately collected income tax.
Mombers left a new comment on the post We own land! Give us money!":
Out of interest, I wonder how the means testing of rent controls works?
"Apartments can be deregulated under rent stabilisation if they are vacated at a monthly rent of $2,500 (£1,600) or if they reach that rate and the occupant's income reaches $200,000."
So does your landlord get access to your private financial data?
One would assume so - a bit like the tax office.
And do they really get to keep a portion of your income above $200k for doing precisely nothing...
Clearly yes. It's not clear from the article how much, but broadly speaking a percentage of it - a bit like income tax.
... or does that money somehow end up going to the public purse?
The landlord in turn will pay some income tax on that 'income tax' he has collected from you.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
13:52
5
comments
Labels: Income Tax, New York, Rent controls
Monday, 11 August 2014
Fun Online Polls: Private landlords & Alcohol health warnings
The responses to last week's Fun Online Poll were as follows:
Which statement is correct: Private landlords in the UK…
… pay more in income tax than they receive in Housing Benefit - 17%
… receive more in Housing Benefit than than they pay in income tax - 83%
So most of you got it right.
There is no official figure for income tax paid on rental income. HMRC's Table 3.4 says that total income tax paid on "Property, interest, dividend and other income" was £10.8 billion in 2011-12, I can't find a more up to date figure. Let's assume half of that is on rental income = £5.4 billion. If you do a fair guesstimate of what they would be paying assuming the usual deductions and exemptions, the tax would be about £6 - £7 billion a year.
So let's call it £6 billion for sake of argument.
The figure for Housing Benefit paid to private sector landlords is more reliable. According to the DWP, in 2012-13 there are about 1.7 million claimants in the private rented sector receiving an average of £105 a week each = £9.1 billion a year.
John says: "The tax regime in this country allows setting buy to let mortgage against tax bill stupid not to."
Yes, there is a pretence that rental income is normal earned income, so you can deduct interest paid from taxable rental income. But then again, rental income is treated as unearned income for National Insurance purposes, i.e. there isn't any. So that's a win-win.
Proper earned income is liable to NIC; and interest is not an allowable deduction against investment income (except in certain very narrow circumstances, which are quite reasonable).
-----------------------------------
The bansturbators are having another field day:
Health warnings on alcoholic drinks should be introduced to combat problem drinking, a parliamentary group says.
The All-Party Parliamentary Group on Alcohol Misuse said labels should warn about the harmful effects of drinking.
So that's this week's Fun Online Poll.
Vote here or use the widget in the sidebar.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
11:20
0
comments
Labels: Bansturbation, FOP, Housing Benefit, Income Tax, landlords
Monday, 4 August 2014
Fun Online Polls: Private landlords
I was doing some more research taxes and subsidies in the UK housing market and stumbled across another interesting statistic.
See if you can guess using the widget in the sidebar.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
08:02
3
comments
Labels: Housing Benefit, Income Tax
Monday, 30 June 2014
Sumoking's Libertarian Corner
Posted by
SumoKing
at
15:12
3
comments
Labels: Government spending, Income Tax, Libertarianism
Thursday, 20 March 2014
"Why Osborne should now axe tax relief on pensions"
Graeme Leach thinks outside the box in City AM Forum:
It sounds controversial, but the progressive withdrawal of tax relief for pensions, as long as it’s used to finance direct cuts in income tax and national insurance, could be a game changer.
Tax relief on pensions costs £42bn per annum, when you add together reliefs on income tax (employer and employee) and national insurance (employer).
Given that just £30bn a year would let you reduce the standard rate of income tax from 20 to 15 per cent, and the higher and top rates to 30 per cent from 40 and 45 per cent, that’s an awful lot of money to make the case for less government.
Excellent plan, I've been saying this for ages. The so-called tax breaks for pensions all get nicked by the 'pensions industry' anyway.
Even better would be to get rid of income tax entirely*, it's not the worst tax, but all the stupid income tax breaks (mainly for pensions) are by and large absolutely awful subsidies (i.e. to the rent seekers in the financial sector); without income tax, there'd be no need for income tax breaks either.
* A flat annual charge of 2.5% of the current potential selling price of all residential housing would raise enough money to get rid of income tax; there'd be many more winners than losers, nobody would have to bother with a self-assessment return, running PAYE would be a lot simpler (NIC only) and corporation tax would be entirely voluntary - if you don't want your business to pay corporation tax, then just become a sole trader or a partnership again.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
10:16
3
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Pensions, Taxation
Thursday, 2 January 2014
Your handy cut-out and keep guide: Poll tax, land value tax, income tax
Here's a summary of my longer article at KAALVTN:

I just don't get it.
How can LVT-opponents simultaneously claim that both poll tax and income tax are preferable to LVT? That's like you saying that 20 degrees is an uncomfortable temperature and that you'd prefer a mixture of 10 degrees and 30 degrees.
AFAICS, LVT has all the advantages of Income Tax (with none of the disadvantages); all the advantages of a Poll Tax (with none of the disadvantages); and beats both hands down in other respects. LVT is the Goldilocks tax which sits comfortably in the middle.
If you want, you can make LVT a bit more like a Poll Tax* or you can make LVT more like Income Tax**. Or indeed you could do both at the same time, although I'm not really sure what the point of that would be, unless you really want the base the entire tax system on the narrow interests of a tiny minority of Poor Widows In Mansions.
* Under Domestic Rates, the tax payable for the most expensive homes was a hundred times as much as for the cheapest; with Council Tax the ratio is only four-to-one, in other words Council Tax has a large Poll Tax element and a small ad valorem element.
** By having discounts or exemptions for lower earners in high value housing, capping a household's LVT bill at a certain percentage of total income and/or by having a deferment/roll-up option for pensioners.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
10:49
12
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Land Value Tax, Poll Tax
Friday, 23 August 2013
"Income tax hits 'ordinary workers in south-east'"
Ben Weenen on top form at The Institute of Directors:
The tax needs armies of bureaucrats to administer and destabilises the job market, says IoD Director General Simon Walker.
The so-called income tax – favoured by some opposition politicians – is wrongly directed and amounts to a tax on Britain’s south-east. This is where 80 per cent of the high income earners affected are located and which pays more than its share of government outgoings already.
The tax isn’t just targeted at incomes earned by rich foreigners and overpaid bankers. Most of those who are hit are ordinary workers whose earnings have dropped in real terms over recent decades through no fault of their own but as a result of successive government policies.
According to Treasury estimates, the £160bn targeted from such a tax would means an average annual charge of £5,500 for workers affected (rising to over £100,000 a year for London's highest earners). The madness of London wages means that the tax is demanded from workers earning as little as £10,000 a year, barely a living wage in London and has led to a massive destabilisation in the jobs market.
Motivation for the tax – a populist gesture aimed at punishing the poor – was signposted by a Tory Treasury spokesman who claimed that for the 55 per cent of people who do not have a job, this is a popular policy.
Income tax requires armies of bureaucrats and accountants to administer, and artificially encourages cash in hand and avoidance – a windfall for lawyers and tax advisors.
UK income taxes are already higher than in all the other OECD countries, with well paid jobs also subject to National Insurance. More determinedly enterprising Countries such as Hong Kong and Singapore have far lower taxes on incomes, preferring property taxes instead. In Hong Kong, 45% of all revenues come from property.
Politicians may be hoping to prove the adage that if they rob Peter to pay Paul, they can count on Paul’s vote. But governments are elected to govern fairly for all. A populist tax directed at hard-working individuals because they’re easy targets negates fairness and delegitimises the system.
Imposing Income Tax is madness. It costs millions of jobs and shrinks the economy. This flies in the face of the Conservative Party being pro-work, and pro-enterprise. This measure to shift the burden of taxation away from rents and monopolies onto work and profits only rewards rent seekers and monopolists.
As the Director General of the IOD I can without equivocation condemn this nakedly anti-business policy."
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
09:21
4
comments
Labels: Home-Owner-Ism, Income Tax, Institute of Directors, Mansion Tax
Monday, 4 February 2013
"The extreme geography of income wealth"
To continue the theme of the previous post ( via City AM) HMRC's Table 2.5 gives a breakdown of Income tax liabilities by income range for 2012-13:
Top 0.1%
Incomes over £500,000, total incomes £44.8 billion, total income tax paid £19.7 billion
Rest of top 1%
Incomes £150,000 to £500,000, total incomes £60.7 billion, total income tax paid £22.5 billion.
Rest of top 10%
Incomes £50,000 to £150,000, total incomes £195.5 billion, total income tax paid £46.6 billion.
Next 45%
Incomes £20,000 to £50,000, total incomes £409 billion, total income tax paid £56.3 billion.
Bottom 45%
Incomes £8,105 to £20,000, total incomes £191.8 billion, total income tax paid £13.9 billion.
Non taxpayers
Approx. 40% of adults with taxable income of £8,105 or less.
Of course, income tax alone is only a quarter of all taxes paid, but assuming that taxes on income and personal wealth generally were halved, the top one per cent would have no problems paying the LVT on their houses based on current site-only rental values (approx. 3% of current selling prices), which would be somewhere in the region of £20 billion a year.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
10:55
0
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Inequality, Taxation
Wednesday, 3 October 2012
Fun In The Sun
I originally saw this article in The Sun, but I can't track it down there, so let's refer to a similar article in The Daily Mail:
Today Treasury ministers said Labour's existing proposal for a reduction in VAT from 20 per cent to 17.5 per cent would cost £12.5 billion this year.
Sajid Javid, Economic Secretary to the Treasury, said: "Labour have let the cat out of the bag – if elected, their plans mean a £500 tax bombshell for every person who works hard and wants to get on in life. Labour isn't learning. They still stand for more borrowing and more debt - and higher taxes."
What a splendid bit of Indian Bicycle Marketing!
The Tories reduced, or plan to reduce, income tax/corporation tax ever so slightly, but got their retaliation in first by hiking the worst taxes of all, VAT and National Insurance, by 2.5% and 2% respectively shortly after taking over (whether Labour would have done the same is a moot point, they probably would, as it happens). The overall effect is a nice tax cut for the usual suspects - banks, bankers and large landowners and a correspondingly larger tax hike on the productive economy (the headline corporation tax cut was largely funded by a further reduction in capital allowances; the overseas earnings exemption primarily benefits banks).
Those two tax hikes amounted to £23 billion or something, which is a "tax bombshell" of £700-plus for each "hard-working taxpayer". Now Labour say they would reverse one of these tax hikes, which in the trade is referred to as a "£12.5 billion cost"* and would, apparently, hike income tax slightly instead, the overall effect of which will be £nil.
As to "more borrowing and more debt - and higher taxes", I think that's a very fair summary of what the Tories have been up to so far, isn't it?
* If the other party calls for a tax cut, it's a "cost" and if they call for a tax hike it's a "bombshell". Those Are The Rules of Indian Bicycle Marketing.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
18:30
2
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Indian bicycle market, VAT
Tuesday, 25 September 2012
"German Catholics lose church rights for unpaid tax"
From the BBC:
Germany's Roman Catholics are to be denied the right to Holy Communion or religious burial if they stop paying a special church tax.
A German bishops' decree which has just come into force says anyone failing to pay the tax - an extra 8% of their income tax bill - will no longer be considered a Catholic.
The bishops have been alarmed by the number of Catholics leaving the Church. They say such a step should be seen as a serious act against the community.
This is not really news, as the Kirchensteuer surcharge has been part of the German tax system since the 19th century. You have always been able to opt out, and when I worked there, none of my employers ever asked me whether I wanted to pay it, which saved me the hassle of explaining that a) I'm an atheist and b) I've no interest in paying a Pfennig more in tax than I have to.
The unanswered question always was: what happens if you do opt out? Surprisingly few of my clients ever did. The answer must have been that you are ex-communicated (or whatever the equivalent is for Protestants), meaning you can't go to Heaven, but then of course, the next question would be, what happens if you opt in again for the last few months of your life? Does that buy you a place in Heaven or would you have to pay back tax for the missing years? What if a German Christian were to move abroad for a few years and thus not be able to pay the tax? And so on.
Nobody ever really talked about all this, and as far as I am aware, people who opted out were no more likely to be killed by bolts of lightning or falling trees than anybody else.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
10:54
13
comments
Labels: Germany, Income Tax, Religion
Wednesday, 11 April 2012
Granny Tax 2: Storm In A Teacup
There's a splendid bit of misinformation in The Daily Mail:
Advisers to George Osborne are calling for a new ‘granny tax’ that will fuel public anger at the Government’s treatment of the elderly. The Chancellor will be presented with plans to tax the basic state pension at source which could leave many pensioners with a cash flow problem.(1)
Some six million pensioners pay tax. But the state pension, which has just risen from £102.15 to £107.45 a week, is currently paid before tax is deducted.(2) The Office of Tax Simplification (OTS), which advises the Treasury on tax matters, is calling on the Government to take tax when the state pension is paid.(3) That would reduce it for those paying basic rate tax to £85.96 a week and to £64.47 for those on the 40 per cent rate.(4)
1) Nope, deducting tax at source (to the extent that this is mathematically possible) will make life a lot easier and if anything it will ease cash flow problems.
2) The current rules are that the basic and second state pension is paid gross. It counts as taxable income and so uses up the personal allowance. I don't know if the full basic state pension plus maximum SERPS/S2P can ever exceed the personal allowance of £10,500 or more (it is a while since I've done a pensioner's income tax return) - for nine of ten, the state pension will be less than the personal allowance so no tax could or would or could be deducted. If the total state pension is less than the age-related personal allowance is then offset against other regular pension income (via the PAYE code used for that other pension) or can be claimed on a Self-Assessment tax return if the pensioner has other income with tax deducted at source.
3) I've skim read the OTS review of pensioners' taxation and see no mention of it, but maybe it came up in conversation.
4) Nope, see (2). If somebody had £11,000 a year total state pension, then the excess of a few hundred quid above the age-related personal allowance would have 20% tax deducted. So a £210 a week pension would have about £2 a week tax deducted, somebody with a pension of only £107 a week pension would not have any tax deducted.
-------------------------------
They're still doing it all wrong.
a. IDS has come up with (well he nicked it off me and I in turn nicked it off the Lib Dems, long story) the bright idea of a Citizen's Pension ('CP'). Good start. That's the government giving pensioners money, nice and simple. Then along comes the government, in the form of the taxman, and takes some back. Can't the two departments or ministers concerned have a little chat and iron out their differences?
b. Surely it cannot be beyond the wit of mankind to align the CP with the age-related personal allowance ('APA'), so that every pensioner gets the CP paid gross, no tax deducted and all other income (mainly bank interest, ha, and other pensions) just have 20% tax deducted at source - but without a significant number of pensioners ending up better or worse off?
c. For example, if the CP is increased, that costs the government money £1 for £1 paid out; if the age-related personal allowance is reduced, that saves the government money 20p for every £1 of reduction. So instead of a CP of (say) £7,500 per annum and an APA of £10,500, they could have a CP of £8,000 (so every pensioner gets extra £500 a year) and an APA of £8,000 (so wealthier pensioners have an additional £500 extra basic rate tax deducted at source). Poorer pensioners end up a bit better off and wealthier pensioners end up the same.
d. While we're at it, let's get rid of the residual savings rate band of 10% and the 30% stealth rate band for pensioner income between £25,400 and (about) £30,000. Scrapping the 10% band would mean a few people with a low-ish pension and quite a lot of interest income lose up to £271 a year; scrapping the 30% stealth band would mean a few people with pretty decent pensions would gain up to £240 a year. The two cancel out, and seeing as pensioners at the bottom end are £500 a year better off from c, I see no need for any further measures.
e. Finally, let's get rid of the age-related married couple's allowance where one spouse or civil partner was born before the Canadian science fiction writer Douglas Arthur Hill while we're at it, which is an extra £296 a year (or up to £770 if you are in some bizarre marginal rate band). That figure is per couple, so also not worth replacing with anything.
f. Again, there will be squealing and wailing involved, but it's a one-off thing and people will get used to it, let's round things off by rounding up the CP from £8,000 to £8,105 per person, to align the CP/APA with the normal personal allowance of £8,105, then even better. If the whole exercise ends up too expensive, then we can just scrap the winter fuel allowance or free TV licence, free bus pass or something to keep it fiscally neutral.
g. It will save the Chancellor the hassle of announcing all the updated amounts for the state pension and the personal allowances and bands separately, he can just increase the general personal allowance, and the CP/APA moves up in line; and very few pensioners will have the hassle of doing a tax return.
NOW That's what I call simple!
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
07:19
0
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Office For Tax Simplification, Pensions, Simplification
Friday, 23 March 2012
"HM Revenue & Customs: The Exchequer effect of the 50 per cent additional rate of income tax"
I've reverse engineered the calculations they made in explaining why cutting the 50p top income tax rate to 45p would probably be revenue-neutral (see their calculations and explanations on page 15 and the chart on page 51) and I've embedded the key part of the spreadsheet below for your entertainment.
Their aim seems to be to set the income tax rate at the revenue-maximising rate, there are a few of problems with this:
1. They accept 12.8% Employer's NIC and 1% Employee's NIC as a given, even though these have both increased by 1% and are just another layer of income tax.
2. They cheerfully admit that they have no idea what the elasticity of supply of labour is (which they refine slightly and refer to as 'Taxable Income Elasticity' or TIE). On pages 18 and 19 they summarise lots of studies from various countries which give figures between 0.2 (people continue working and paying tax, even if wages fall and/or tax rates increase) and 0.8 (people will work less, avoid or evade taxes, move abroad etc if wages fall and/or tax rates increase), ignoring outliers. They can't make up their minds whether to use 0.35, 0.45 or 0.55 (so their chart uses all three).
3. As the calculations show, this is the most important unknown of all; if you assume a low sensitivity of 0.2, then the revenue-maximising income tax rate (i.e. the top of the Laffer curve) is 67%, and if you assume a high sensitivity of 0.8 it's 35%. Of course, different people respond differently; the rate might be different for high earners and low earners; the short term responsiveness might be more or less than long term etc.
4. They say that TIE can be split up into three things: labour supply (people work less or move abroad), tax planning (people work just as much but use legal loopholes) and evasion (people work just as much but do it cash-in-hand), and say the labour supply effect is "between one-third and one-half of the total TIE". This is their roundabout way of admitting that taxes on income have dead weight costs.
5. Those dead weight costs are also an incredibly important consideration. My spreadsheet shows the fall in potential GDP in the last row, i.e. the fall in declared taxable income multiplied by 0.4, which seems to come out at between 10% and 15%. That's a heck of a lot of lost output and unnecessary unemployment, by the way.
The figure for total revenues assumes that GDP starts at 100, with a flat income tax rate of 10% and National Insurance still in place (even these low rates must depress GDP by five per cent or so, let's gloss over that).
6. Another thing they ought to consider is that the cost of welfare is just an upside down Laffer curve; the way to minimise the cost of means-tested benefits is to find out what the revenue-maximising tax rate on lower earners with a small independent income would be and then to use that as the marginal withdrawal rate.
As a matter of fact, marginal withdrawal rates (especially for people who have tax deducted and benefits withdrawn at the same time) are between 70% and 100%, which is way beyond the top of the Laffer curve - in other words, we could reduce the cost of means-tested welfare by reducing income-based means-testing, although that point seems to escape them.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
22:27
2
comments
Labels: Excel, Income Tax, Laffer, Maths, Welfare reform
Tuesday, 13 March 2012
"Income tax plan is foiled by Osborne: Treasury 'deletes' earnings data"
From The Daily Mail:
Schemes for an ‘income tax’ have been torpedoed by George Osborne after he effectively deleted a database compiled by HM Revenue & Customs spies containing details of millions of people's earnings. The move means that any levy on incomes would now take years to introduce...
Officials say it would take three years to conduct a new nationwide survey of wages and salaries. Inspectors at HM Revenue & Customs had logged details of the wages paid to 25 million employees England and Wales. Other information included whether an employee received benefits in kind such as a company car. The data, which would be crucial for deciding who should pay how much income tax, had been entered into a complex database – but Mr Osborne ruled out using it until at least 2015.
Income tax assessments in Wales in 2005 saw four times as many people being taxed on higher incomes than previous assessments in 1991, and Labour postponed plans for new income tax assessments in England that same year amid mounting anger over the potential for big tax rises hitting middle-class families whose earnings had gone up over the previous fourteen years.
Tory MP Peter Bone praised Mr Osborne's decision.
"This income tax would cost goodness know how many millions to get up and running," he said. "People would suddenly be reminded that they were earning a lot more than they did twenty-one years ago, very often having worked for the same employer for years and years or perhaps living off investment income from inherited wealth.
"We know the Liberals don’t like anyone that has been successful but this really would be an unfair tax. It’s good that the Government has got rid of the information that could have been used to calculate it – why should the State be keeping databases like this?"
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
17:09
9
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Mansion Tax, Obesity
Wednesday, 29 February 2012
Newsflash: the personal allowance IS £10,000
The coalition is making a big song and dance about the plans to increase the income tax free personal allowance to £10,000 (all figues per annum). The official income-tax free personal allowance was only £6,475 in 2009-10 and it's £7,475 in the current tax year 2011-12, which looks like slow progress.
The truth of the matter is, the effective tax-free personal allowance is already £10,000 and has only increased by £493 in the two years since the coalition took over; the benefit of the higher personal allowance has been more or less wiped out by the total 4% increase in National Insurance and Working Tax Credits withdrawal.
Assuming that you consider National Insurance to be income tax (which I do)* and assuming that you consider Working Tax Credits to be negative income tax (for statisical purposes, they are), then if a single low earner had a gross pay of £9,507 in 2009-10, the total income tax/Employee's NIC/Employer's NIC payable was £1,506; and his Working Tax Credits were also £1,506, net nothing (apart from lots of jobs for bureacrats).
The same calculation using 2011-12 rates show that at gross pay of exactly £10,000, the total tax/NIC payable is £1,242, and the total Working Tax Credits are £1,242.
Given that price inflation was about 9% over the past two years, a 4% increase in the effective tax-free personal allowance means that the real tax-free personal allowance has fallen.
You can look up the rates here and check PAYE calculations here.
Just sayin', is all.
* If you assume that Employer's bear the Employer's NIC, the increase is even less spectacular, and has only gone up from £10,200 to £10,5555 over the two years.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
10:50
3
comments
Labels: Income Tax, Maths, National Insurance, Tax Credits
Tuesday, 31 January 2012
Stealth Tax Fun
You can download the main rates of tax on earned income at the HMRC website. The official basic rate of income tax has come down from 35% to 20% since 1975, but this is completely misleading, as this was merely offset with corresponding increases in every politician's favourite stealth taxes: VAT (currently 20%), Employer's National Insurance (currently 13.8%) and Employee's National Insurance (currently 12%).
You can't just add the rates together, the overall rate is (thankfully) not 20% + 13.8% + 12% + 20% = 65.8%. The more scientific approach is to ask, if you as a consumer spend £1 on the output of a non-monopoly, non-special-interest business, how much does the government take before an average employee can be paid?*
As we see, the overall effective rate has stayed pretty constant at around 50% since shortly after VAT was first introduced, so the benefits of the basic rate income tax reduction are only felt by certain favoured groups or certain favoured sources of income:
* For illustration, using this year's rates, for every £1 you spend...
- VAT is not 20% of that, it's one-sixth of that, i.e. 20/120 = 16.7p goes in VAT;
- This leaves 83.3p out of which wages are paid. Employer's NIC is 13.8%, so Employer's NIC is 13.8/113.8 of the 83.3p that's left after VAT = 10.1p goes in Employer's NIC;
- This leaves a maximum of 73.2p to be paid out as wages;
- Employee's NIC is 12% of 73.2p = 8.8p goes in Employee's NIC;
- Basic Rate Income Tax is 20% of 73.2p = 14.6p goes in Basic Rate Income Tax.
Posted by
Mark Wadsworth
at
09:27
8
comments
Labels: Income Tax, National Insurance, Taxation, VAT
