Showing posts with label ERSA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ERSA. Show all posts

Monday, 8 July 2013

Off Topic - no way!

The Welfare to Work UK Convention 2013 kicks off tomorrow in Manchester, theme "Employment and skills - opportunity for all" - with all the usual suspects attending/sponsoring of course - 

and from the event programme what an interesting topic has been chosen for the very first "Convention debate":-


Now before anyone asks "what has the emerging justice market" got to do with Welfare to Work and starts muttering that this is just "the real beneficiaries of Welfare to Work " gathered together for a beano celebrating how they have benefited from one "taxpayer funded pot of gold" and what can be done to keep it going - Work Programme II is on the agenda - taking the opportunity of all being together at "the best networking opportunity of the year" to "investigate" how they will benefit from another being launched by the Ministry of Justice .......

Thursday, 20 June 2013

"The DWP conned us, and our members" says a visibly upset Employment Related Services Association

"dangling the carrot of 'easy money' for 'helping' those out of work find work, and now we find we are expected to actually do something for the money, it isn't fair..." or if you prefer the properly balanced BBC version of the tale:

Work Programme 'not doing enough'

"The costs of helping jobseekers on ESA back into work are significant and cannot all be met by the Work Programme," says the Association's chief executive, Kirsty McHugh. "In order for there to be a significant step change in performance in helping these jobseekers into employment, we need greater use of skills and health budgets."

And to give the BBC credit it manages to sum up that plea from ERSA very nicely indeed :-

The call for spending from other parts of the public sector to be channelled in to support the Work Programme is an embarrassment for this flagship government scheme.

Well yes, another example of the "do it so much better" private sector asking that it be allowed to pass the burden of doing what it is contracted to do over to the failing "public sector" whilst this not impacting on its "payment by (sic) results" profits.

But interestingly ERSA are not castigating Atos, holder of the DWP issued contract for reassessing Incapacity Benefit holders for ESA, and new ESA claims, which is resulting in all these "people declared not ill and suitable for undertaking work" who are now being directed at the Work Programme providers to actually complete the chain and find them that work.

The Department for Work and Pensions says the payment-by-results contracts agreed with Work Programme providers already give them "a clear financial incentive to support the hardest to help into work".

Oh dear, the initial DWP response to the "can we renegotiate the entire contract two years in" plea from ERSA seems to be a firm, if carefully worded "no way". Wonder how long that line will be maintained.

Monday, 20 May 2013

Well duh!

Work Programme staff struggle to help unemployed when 'jobs aren't there'

Well, slap me down with a wet fish, who would have thought it. Think it we might but what we must remember is that various really clever people holding important positions in governments present and past had an inkling that that might be the case, which is why they set up highly expensive because they are so really clever special schemes operated by the people with the right sort of proven expertise and skills and connections to just bypass that and get at least 3 unemployed people into "long term" work for every single job vacancy declared … Clever or not, the article seems to suggest that “all is not going well” and things are being made oh so difficult by the absence of...

Thursday, 18 April 2013

We can obviously have every confidence that the tail is not wagging the dog and that

The Department for Work and Pensions has the most rigid and painstaking system for approving claims for "placement and sustained placement payments" submitted by the Work Programme providers - certainly nothing like "If they say they've placed someone in a job, then that's a PR bonus for us and our impeccable, if "simple" statistics on the success of the Programme, so just pay it"?

Item 1.  22 February 2013 - the PAC publish their report on the first 14 months of the Work Programme


The government's flagship multibillion-pound programme for helping the long-term unemployed into work has been branded "extremely poor" in a damning assessment by MPs. Margaret Hodge, who chairs the committee, said the programme was particularly failing young people and the hardest to help.
She also criticised the DWP for publishing unvalidated data from a trade body representing Work Programme providers, saying: "This is just not on."
The " trade body representing Work Programme providers" is of course ERSA (who are these days proudly boasting on their website about how "ERSA has speareheaded [sic] the establishment of the IEP, a professional body for the employability sector.)  The "unvalidated data" concerned ERSA collated data showing that "200,000 people had been placed in work" which the DWP had duly republished as "the results of the Work programme".

Item 2.  also 22 February 2013 - from the DWP Statement in response to Public Accounts Committee report on the Work Programme

A DWP spokesperson said:   "This report (22/02/13) paints a skewed picture.  More than 200,000 people have moved off benefits and into a job thanks to the Work Programme."
A sort of "If we say it's ok to publish data provided by our contractors as our "performance stats" it's ok, ok?" and they also repeated it in the "detailed breakdown of performance outcomes" provided in the response to the PAC.

How is the Work Programme performing?

Official statistics showed that from June 2011 until July 2012:

•31,200 participants had stayed in work for long enough to achieve a job “outcome” – that means they stayed in work for a sustained period and the organisation has claimed a payment.

•Of those, 19,300 had been in work for at least six months and 11,900 for at least three months.

•Of those who joined the Work Programme in June 2011, 9.8% had been in sustained work.

Data from industry body the Employment Related Services Association showed that by September 2012:

•Over 200,000 participants had got off benefits and into work.
Anyone spot the seamless transition from "official statistics " into "impeccable ERSA data also subsequently quoted in a way to give the impression they were also "official statistics"?

Item 3.   How it happened - from PE Issue 1338 (Page 10) - click on to enlarge


Anyone who suggests that when the next set of WP Performance data is issued, should it show a "miraculous improvement" before breaking into unrestrained applause it would be wise to wait until someone outside the DWP and ERSA has had a look at the base data behind it, and especially to see if in fact there is any,  is obviously a complete cynic.

Sunday, 14 April 2013

It isn't fair, lots and lots of easy money for doing bugger all or less than bugger all is what we signed up for

and we demand that we get it and continue to get it and we’d like some more

All is not well with the Work Programme the G informs us :-

Work Programme can't keep up with number of jobless, government told

and specifically 

The coalition's flagship Work Programme for the long-term unemployed is failing because there are just too many people needing help, according to a government report.

Yes indeed, there are a lot of unemployed people, and people who were receipt of incapacity benefit who have been retested as a result of the ending of that particular benefit and been informed that they don’t qualify for its replacement ESA, being fit enough to work, and must find themselves a job, and we can also add in former Remploy staff  …. 

Any way, the organisations which hold the “prime contracts” for the Work Programme, having been told not so long ago that they really must improve their performance significantly; having managed in the first 14 months of the Work Programme to deliver outcomes on “job placements” which were only half as good as job seekers were managing to achieve off their own bat when the WP didn’t exist, are finding it “hard going” when it comes to delivering what they contracted to deliver …

The quality of the service is being affected by the high level of demand, according to the companies responsible for training the unemployed.

There would appear to be a lot more “job seekers” than the WP providers were ever told existed … which is slightly odd, I am sure most would agree.   

The alternative, that they took on too much and promised too much when they signed up to the contracts, and are now agitating for a watering down of the targets in those contracts, or failing that, lots more up front government funds in advance of even getting their outcome figures at or above the year one target, never mind we are now well in to year two with supposedly far higher promised outcomes, is ridiculous.

As is evident from these comments from “members of the public” reacting to the G tale..

Recommend 7

Now there's a surprise.   They know they have the government over a barrel, it being a high-profile policy, So they will be looking for extra funding to do what they have  contracted to deliver. With a threat that they'll walk away if they don't get it.  Oh, the joys of private sector provision.

Recommend 5

Work Programme can't keep up with number of jobless, government told.
Private firms in flagship back-to-work scheme complain of too little funding and too much demand

De-bullshitted that actually means...

Private firms that submitted inept, misleading and potentially fraudulent tenders to secure access to huge sums of public money now admit to their incompetence and generally falsified ability to honour public contracts in any way...  and by the way ....   they think they deserve extra money for being such total lying, and aggressively fraudulent (allegedly - by their own inference) wastes of space.
If you can't deliver DON'T SUBMIT ERRONEOUS BIDS that merely underline the fact you DO NOT even comprehend the task in hand and the scale of its demands.
     
Utter arseholes tendering to a government of the same.  If they were bridge builders every attempt would turn out like the famous Pont D'Avignon ...  But more costly.

Thursday, 21 March 2013

“Of course we aren’t “gagging” public servants


"they are completely free to express how brilliant our outsourcing schemes are in any arena they wish !” said a government spokesperson, seeking to rebut suggestions that the government was becoming increasingly heavy handed in its treatment of public servants who voice “negative” opinions about the government’s vital “corporate welfare” initiatives. 

The intervention had been sparked by an article in the Guardian newspaper concerning instructions issued to staff working in the National Offender Management Service – colloquially known as the Prison Service and Probation Service – warning them, on pains of disciplinary consequences up to and including dismissal, not to write blogs or issue comments via Twitter, nor to venture such opinions to journalists etc. criticising Chris Grayling’s plan for “outsourcing” the management and rehabilitation of 'low risk' offenders to “the usual suspects”.

Referring specifically to the planned “Offender rehabilitation” outsourcing the spokesperson explained that “This idea builds on Chris Grayling’s experiences at the DWP; where he was the Minister responsible for the Work Programme, which as everyone knows is a cracking success, with results so far indicating that it is close to half as effective as having no “Work Programme” at all.   

He has invited those organisations that have benefited from the Work Programme to bid to run “offender rehabilitation programmes for low level, low risk offenders” under similar arrangements.  The long term likelihood is that by doing this he is safeguarding the jobs of NOMS staff because the successful bidders will need people experienced in this sort of work and, rather than incur the expense of recruiting and training them to an acceptable required standard will probably themselves simply publish offers of “sub contracts” under the scheme that local Probation Services will be able to bid for – the “outsourced work being immediately re-insourced” if you will. 

This system is known to work because Atos, under the contract it has with the DWP for carrying out Work Capability Assessments, already re-insources some of this work to the NHS, and still manages to make a nice profit from the contract."