Thursday, 9 March 2017

Adam Smith Institute FAIL

From City AM:

How did people react to the National Insurance hike?

Sam Dumitriu at the Adam Smith Institute said: “It’s right to bring National Insurance on the self-employed in line with that paid by employees. But the chancellor must ensure he is not discouraging the self-employed from investing, and allow them to immediately deduct capital expenditures from their taxable income...


LOLZ! has he not heard of the Annual Investment Allowance, which means that most small and medium-sized business can claim 100% of their capital expenditure in the first year? (This is some nonsense dreamed by Georgon Osbrown: reduce the normal capital allowance rate to a miserly 18% (or 8%) but then give most businesses a 100% rate anyway).

... We shouldn’t be looking to increase the overall tax burden, especially not on low-income workers. So we should use the extra revenue raised to cut the overall National Insurance rate.”

If he means align the NIC rate on employees and self-employed, they've got a long way to go (10% vs 23% on the first £43,000), even further if they look the rates above that (2% and 14%) and even further if they look at the NIC rates on investment and rental income (0%). But the Annual Investment Allowance (which is only a timing thing anyway) is bugger all use to low-income self-employed who probably don't incur much capital expenditure.

To give Philip Hammond credit, he did point out that employees pay/suffer two layers of NIC and IIRC, referred to it as a "tax".

5 comments:

Lola said...

Quite. If 'Spreadshit Phil' had levelled down employees NIC that'd be great - reducing 'payroll taxes'. That could make employing people more attractive to many employers. But you have to bear in mind that the s/e don't get any of the 'protections' employees get.

Mike W said...

Lola above, 'Spreadshit Phil'. Very Good, obviously another one that I will be using in the coming weeks. I'm stumped with getting a gag out of Excel though:)

When my wife and I have ran small business/ freelancers we always took the low NI as another incentive/perk from Gov, that we would give up PAYE jobs to run our own business (along with all the other 'dual use','business expense' stuff on the balance sheet). Just how we viewed it from the grassroots. But agree with the point that reducing down, NIC for PAYE, is a must do for all the reasons we have discussed before .

Mike W said...

Just thought, Oh God what have we done! Daily Mail, - 'Excel-ent Hammond'... is there? Did the Sun?

Mark Wadsworth said...

L, yes of course.

MW, keep trying. We'll go with Spreadshit Phil for now.

Shiney said...

If he uses Excel, or M$ Office in general, he's more of a wanker than I first thought.

He should be using LibreOffice, or better still a fag packet, and saving himself (well us taxpayers actually) a shit load of cash.