Showing posts with label Cancer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cancer. Show all posts

Monday, 10 July 2017

Nobody move or the cancer patients get it!

From the front page of today's Evening Standard:

Theresa May today faced a Tory rebellion and a stark warning that “thousands” of cancer patients face delays to their treatment as a direct result of Britain’s decision to quit the European nuclear body Euratom.

The agency, which governs the movement of radioactive material around Europe, is not formally part of the EU but is under the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice — leading to the Government’s decision to pull out as part of the Brexit process.

Monday, 1 June 2015

Cancer Treatment

From the BBC

A fundraising appeal is being launched in Wiltshire to help hundreds of radiotherapy patients receive treatment closer to home.
The Great Western Hospital (GWH) in Swindon needs £2.9m to equip its own radiotherapy cancer treatment centre.
Around 700 people had to undertake a 60-mile round trip to Oxford for treatment in 2013/14 - some doing it several times a week - the NHS said.

I'm curious about the ongoing costs of this. OK, you raise £2.9m for equipment with I guess, a five year lifespan. But now you've got a load of duplication of staff like receptionists, administrators and maintenance people. You no longer have a single centre of excellence - the expertise gets split.

Monday, 30 June 2014

GPs spotting Cancer

From the BBC

GPs with a poor record in spotting signs of cancer could be publicly named under new government plans.

Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt wants to expose doctors whose failure to spot cancer may delay sending patients for potentially life-saving scans.

Labour called the idea "desperate" and accused Mr Hunt of attacking doctors.

The Royal College of GPs said it would be a "crude" system and one that could lead to GPs sending people to specialists indiscriminately.

It warned this could result in flooding hospitals with healthy people.

Which is, actually, what we should be doing. Why go to the monkey, instead of the organ grinder?

I caught a few minutes of the Jeremy Vine show where a former cancer sufferer and someone from the BMA were on and talking about how GPs thought her cancer was IBS, or gallstones. When she got to see a pancreatic specialist, he immediately rushed her into surgery. And it turns out that part of the problem is that some cancers in some areas are very rare, which means that GPs, along with handing out antibiotics for chest infections and prescriptions for the pill and signing passport forms are expected to spot that.

Let's make a comparison with the software industry: when you build a large website, you typically have a range of people involved. You have a graphic designer who makes it pretty, a web designer who takes the design and makes the HTML and CSS code, an accessibility specialist who makes it work fine for disabled people, some internationalisation specialists who make it work with foreign languages and deal with things like building sites for Israel where they are left to right. Then you've got Javascript specialists who make the site do clever things when you press a button. Then engineering guys on the back end that build the code that runs on the servers that checks your password and accepts your orders. Security testers supporting them. And behind those are the database specialists who do the bit of actually storing stuff, and supporting them are the database administrators who make sure the databases are performing right. Oh, and server maintenance too.

I mostly work on the back end of things. I can do a bit of the web design stuff too. But what I know is that if I get a problem in that area, it's going to take a lot longer for me to fix say, something not appearing right in Internet Explorer 8 than a couple of friends that are full-time web designers and instantly know what the problem is. It's not because they're smarter than me - it's because they've been specially trained in those bugs or maybe seen it before, or their boss did, or something else.

15 years ago, you could do the whole job. There was 1 browser to worry about, no-one worried about disabled users, SEO or Russian bots that were hacking websites at random. As things got more complicated, we increased specialisation.

The point I'm trying to make is that for all the "GPs must do this better", that isn't going to work. GPs have a limited amount of time each day and limited experience in fields of medical diagnosis as they're expected to cover everything. They simply aren't going to get the training or experience that tells them that something that on the surface might be a gall stone might be a cancer. Because they're only seeing a few cases of what sounds like gall stones each week, and very few of those are cancer.

On the other hand, if all you do each day is look at possible gallstones, you can either be specially trained to look for cancers, or else, you'll gain the experience of symptoms that means you can make a rapid diagnosis.

So, the real answer here isn't to red flag cancers, it's to get rid of most GPs and train up specialists earlier in various areas of the body. People who can be specially trained in one area, people who can gain knowledge and experience in a particular area.

Thursday, 12 April 2012

Robert Mugabe's cancer loses battle

From The Daily Mirror:

ZANU-PF claims that prostate cancer has abandoned its brave fight against dictator Robert Mugabe, who arrived back in Zimbabwe this morning looking fit and healthy.

The disease, which was rumoured to be battling the 88-year old despot, reportedly suffered a medical procedure while the tyrant was on holiday in Singapore. The tumour was believed to have undergone a biopsy after being removed and was declared benign, according to the Zimbabwe Mail.

Senior officials from Mugabe’s ZANU-PF party dismissed reports that the cancer might take hold again as "a lot a hogwash" from hostile Western media organisations. The tumour's friends and supporters have set up a Facebook group in its memory.

Friday, 30 March 2012

Health Scare Story Du Jour

From the BBC:

Obesity is fuelling a major increase in the number of cases of kidney cancers diagnosed in Britain, experts say.

Cancer Research UK has published figures showing there were just over 9,000 cases in 2009, compared with just under 2,300 in 1975. Obesity increases kidney cancer risk by about 70%, compared with smoking which increases it by about 50%.

Cancer Research UK says too few people understand the cancer risk of being overweight. Kidney cancer is now the eighth most common cancer.


As per usual, it's made up figures time. The chances are there were plenty of kidney cancer deaths in 1975, they just weren't diagnosed or recorded as such. If there are 9,000 'cases' out of over sixty million people, of whom at least fifteen million have been aribtrarily classified as 'obese', that isn't terribly many. And what's a 'case'? A 'death' I understand, but how many of those 'cases' are treated successfully? An increase in the risk of 70% is meaningless unless you know the absolute risk to start off with, either way, only about a third of those 9,000 'cases' are down to obesity*. Smoking looks relatively safe, and if it is indeed true that smoking helps weight loss (supresses appetite), then an obese person can reduce his kidney cancer risk by having a cigarette when he feels hungry. And 'eighth most common cancer', what? What relevance does that have to anything? At a guess, that's only a couple of per cent of all cancer 'cases'. CRUK is a fakecharity. And so on.

* 45 million x normalised risk 1 = 45 million
15 million x heightened risk 1.7 = 25.5 million
25.5 + 45 = 70.5
25.5 ÷ 70.5 = 36%, a bit more than a third.

Thursday, 23 February 2012

Health Scare Stories Du Jour

1. From The Daily Mail:

Mothers who are struggling to get their babies to sleep should consider how much caffeine they are consuming, according to a breast feeding expert. Drinking coffee, tea and soft drinks and even eating chocolate increases the level of the stimulant in the blood. Babies can become restless, awake and irritable, when it is passed on through a mother's milk.

Dr Ruth Lawrence, editor of the journal Breastfeeding Medicine, said that babies have difficulties in breaking down and removing the drug from their bodies especially in their first two weeks of life. This can lead it to accumulate causing adverse symptoms...


The "first two weeks of life"? They'll get over it.

2. While tracking that one down, I stumbled across another coffee/breast related shocker from 2008:

Drinking more than three cups of coffee a day can apparently reduce the size of women's breasts. But it also reduces the risk of cancer, researchers say.

Swedish oncologist Dr Helena Jernstroem said a gene - which half of women have - could react and cause them to a drop a bra size. But she added: "Coffee-drinking women do not have to worry their breasts will shrink to nothing overnight. They will get smaller but the breasts aren't just going to disappear."


Hmm, small boobs or cancer? Not a tough choice, is it?

3. Finally, our GPs are so incompetent, they can't tell whether a patient is alive or dead:

Doctors were receiving money for more than 95,000 people who should have been removed from practice lists in England and Wales, investigators found. Some payments were made for patients who died more 40 years ago.

But many more ghosts may yet be uncovered; there are 52.5 million people in England but 55 million names registered with GPs. With doctors being paid £65 for each patient on their lists, it could mean as much as £162million a year is lost to the NHS...

However, the British Medical Association warned there were reports of ‘over-zealous list cleaners’ removing valid – often vulnerable – patients.


They calculated the £162 million as 2.5 million duplicate/non-existent patients x £65 a year. That's probably woefully understated, as there must be some people who aren't registered with a GP at all.

Interesting use of the word 'vulnerable'. If they come in for regular treatment, then clearly they are valid patients and are not being neglected; if they don't, then why don't the GPs try and track them down to find out why not?

Friday, 17 February 2012

Health scare story du jour

From the BBC:

The speed someone walks may predict the likelihood of developing dementia later in life, according to researchers in the US. They also told a conference that grip strength in middle-age was linked to the chance of a stroke... The researchers said slower walking speeds were linked to a higher risk of dementia and stronger grip with a lower risk of stroke.

This all reminds me a bit of when telling somebody at school that if their hand won't cover the whole of their face, they'll get cancer.

Wednesday, 7 December 2011

Health Scare Story Du Jour

From the BBC:

Over half of cancers diagnosed in the UK each year - 160,000 in total - are not caused by avoidable life choices such as smoking, drinking or eating the wrong things, a review reveals...

The report is published in the British Journal of Cancer. Its authors claim it is the most comprehensive analysis to date on the subject.

Lead author Prof Max Parkin said: "Many people believe cancer is down to fate or 'in the genes' and that it is the luck of the draw whether they get it. Looking at all the evidence, it's clear that this is indeed correct, as around 60% of all cancers are caused by things we have no power to change."

For men, the best advice appears to be: enjoy life while you can, smoke, eat and drink what you. For women, again, the reviews says the best advice is to enjoy life: if slimming is your thing, do it; if not, then tuck in.

Prof Parkin said: "We didn't expect to find that eating fruit and vegetables would prove to be so important in protecting men against cancer. And among women we didn't expect being overweight to be more of a risk factor than alcohol. And to be honest, the statistics are in line with what we expected."

In total, 14 lifestyle factors, such as all the things they keep telling you not to do, and environmental factors, such as where you live and the job you do, still only combine to 134,000 cases of cancer out of a total of 300,000 cases in the UK each year.

Saturday, 16 July 2011

FakeCharities under the Lib-Cons

As I said a while back, "... under the Lib-Cons fakeprivatecompanies and industry-lobby-groups-masquerading-as-charities ('ILGMACs') will take the place of the much loved fakecharities in setting the agenda (i.e. dictating 'regulation and legislation') and/or directing how taxpayers' money is to be spent."

Adam Collyer describes the machinations of a specific ILGMAC here. Worth reading in full.

Sunday, 19 June 2011

Brian Haw

Didn't make it.

Terrible shame, he's the sort of person who makes me proud to be British.

Friday, 3 June 2011

Get Well Soon

Wednesday, 18 May 2011

Health Not Scare Story Du Jour

From the BBC:

Coffee has been linked to a reduced risk of dying from prostate cancer in a study of nearly 50,000 US men.

Those who drank six or more cups a day were found to be 20% less likely to develop any form of the disease - which is the most common cancer in men. They were also 60% less likely to develop an aggressive form which can spread to other parts of the body...


That's great news, isn't it? Oh, wait...

"But charities say the evidence, reported in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, is still unclear. They do not recommend that men take up coffee drinking in the hope of preventing prostate cancer."

At the risk of writing what you're already thinking, do we not suspect that if the study had shown that drinking lots of coffee increased the risk of prostate cancer, these cancer 'charities' would find the evidence to be crystal clear?

PS, the National Cancer Institute is a department of the US government, if that's relevant.

Wednesday, 20 April 2011

Typo Of The Day

From The Metro:

Desk-bound office workers have double risk of bowl cancer

They'll probably correct it later on, but I doubt they'll change the URL.

Friday, 8 April 2011

Health Scare Story Du Jour

Yeah verily, we are all going to die unless we follow the Righteous path of abstinence and Righteousness, trumpets the BBC:

"Drinking more than a pint of beer a day can substantially increase the risk of some cancers, research suggests..."

And so it drones on for several paragraphs, my personal highlight in terms of lies-per-paragraph is this:

Cancer Research UK director of health information Sara Hiom said that many people did not know that drinking alcohol could increase their cancer risk. (1) "In the last 10 years, mouth cancer has become much more common and one reason for this could be because of higher levels of drinking (2) - as this study reflects (3) . Along with being a non-smoker (4) and keeping a healthy bodyweight (5), cutting back on alcohol is one of the most important ways of lowering your cancer risk. (6)"

1) We don't know it because it's not true. That's like saying "Many people don't know that Tiger Woods was born a girl".

2) Alcohol consumption has been flat or falling for the last ten years.

3) No it doesn't.

4) WTF does she drag smoking into it?*

5) WTF does she drag body weight into it?*

6) No it isn't.

* I accept that cumulative risks are not additive, i.e. drinking = not dangerous, driving a car = not dangerous, but drinking and driving at the same time = quite dangerous.

Thursday, 3 March 2011

Now they're just messing with our minds...

From The Times of India:

Researchers have suggested that quitting smoking suddenly could be an early symptom of lung cancer for longtime smokers.

"It is widely known that many lung cancer patients have stopped smoking before diagnosis. This observation is often dismissed, by saying that these patients must have quit because of symptoms of their cancer," said Barbara Campling of the Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia.

"However, we found that the majority of lung cancer patients who stopped smoking before diagnosis quit before the onset of symptoms. Furthermore, they often quit with no difficulty, despite multiple previous unsuccessful quit attempts. This has led us to speculate that, in some cases, spontaneous smoking cessation may be an early symptom of lung cancer," said Campling.


Ho hum. There was a theory doing the rounds that smoking somehow simultaneously causes and suppresses cancer, so once you've started, you're better off if you just keep going - as evidenced by the fact that a lot of people who quit then develop lung cancer. This 'research' turns that logic neatly on its head.

Saturday, 11 December 2010

Health Scare Story Du Jour

According to this, drinking milk is just about as dangerous as smoking.

Problem is, it's not the Daily Mail or somebody saying it, it's Leg-Iron. Would he write this to wind us up?

Ah well, I certainly can't survive without smoking, so I'll see if I can make do without milk, cheese etc. It's the cappuccinos I'll miss. And the cheese, obviously.

Sunday, 15 August 2010

"Britain's oldest smoker dies age 102"

Winnie Langley, we salute you:

Mrs Langley, who smoked her first cigarette aged eight, after the First World War broke out, according to the Croydon Guardian. She died on July 27, a month short of her 103rd birthday. A funeral service was held at Croydon Crematorium* on Tuesday afternoon.

Surviving family member Anne Gibbs told the Croydon Guardian: 'She loved Monopoly and cards and she always had ciggies on the back step. Auntie Winn got cancer when she was 88 but she bounced back. She had a pacemaker fitted when she was 98. She smoked until Christmas last year. She only gave up because she could not see the end of the match to light it.'

Despite battling cancer, Langley had stated that she was not worried about her health due to the fact that she didn't inhale the smoke.


* Thereby releasing 0.9 grams of mercury and 200 grams of chlorine into the atmosphere. I assume they whipped out the pacemaker first.

Wednesday, 16 June 2010

Confusing Health Scare Story Of The Day

From Science Daily:

Among women who drank boiled coffee more than four times a day there was a lowered risk of breast cancer compared with women who drank coffee less than once a day. Among women who drank filtered coffee there was an increased risk for early breast cancer (under 49 years old) and a decreased risk for late breast cancer (over 55 years old). Boiled-coffee drinkers, but not filtered-coffee drinkers, also had an increased risk of pancreatic cancer and lung cancer among men.

Does that mean that women are supposed to stop drinking boiled coffee and start drinking filtered coffee at age 55 or not? Do men fare better by drinking filtered coffee or no coffee at all? And so on.

Tuesday, 15 June 2010

Health Scare Stories Du Jour

They haven't done any 'new research' for a day or two, so we're back to a couple of timeless classics:

From The Metro: "Pregnant women who want to emulate celebrities by wearing high heels are putting their feet at risk, an expert warned."

From The Daily Express: "THE health risks of using mobile phones are far higher than previously thought, scientists warned yesterday."*

* Via JuliaM.

Thursday, 29 April 2010

There are two sides to everything...

Further to my earlier post on CASH (some curries contain 'too much' salt = we are all going to die horribly), I spy this in The Metro:

A curry spice ingredient can make ovarian cancer more responsive to treatment, scientists have shown.

Researchers pre-treated ovarian tumours with curcumin, a component of the yellow spice turmeric, delivered in the form of microscopic "nanoparticles". The curcumin sensitised the cancer tissue, making it more vulnerable to chemotherapy and radiation treatment.


So if you [have ovaries and] eat such curries with 'too much' salt in them, wouldn't that sort of cancel out and be health neutral? Ah...

Study leader Dr Subhash Chauhan, from the University of South Dakota, US, said: "One strategy to improve the effectiveness and limit the toxicity of cancer therapy is to induce chemo/radio-sensitisation in cancer cells using natural dietary phytochemicals like curcumin. However, curcumin is poorly absorbed by the body, which limits its effectiveness.

... ah well.