The BBC have started using the fakecharity article template again:
1. Kick off by quoting a bit of research 'suggesting' something or other:
Teenage smoking rates in England have dropped since the legal age for buying cigarettes rose from 16 to 18, research by University College London suggests. Researchers surveyed more than 1,000 teenagers aged 16 and 17 before and after the age rise in October 2007.
Well duh. It's illegal now, so some 16 or 17 year olds who smoke will simply not admit it.
2. Get a few rent-a-quotes from an appropriate fakecharity:
Jenny Fidler, who led the study and is based at Cancer Research UK's health behaviour research centre at University College London, said: "The new law looks to have helped reduce smoking prevalence among younger age groups. This is good news for the future health of this generation of young people and shows that tobacco policies can make a real difference."
So the research wasn't biased or skewed to try and get a particular result, then?
Jean King, Cancer Research UK's director of tobacco control, said "We need to do more to protect young people. We urge the government to prevent more lives being lost to an addiction that will kill half of all long term smokers."
She said putting tobacco out of sight in shops and removing cigarette vending machines would be a good place to start.
3. Finally, the most important element, and its presence here is most worrying (this element had been missing over the past few months), is for a government spokesman to agree that 'more must be done".
A Department of Health spokesman said they were in discussions across government on how best to progress to tackle smoking.
He added: "We welcome these findings as nearly all adults who smoke get hooked when they are young. Smoking is the biggest preventable cause of death in England, causing over 80,000 premature deaths in England each year."
Put On Your Big Boy Pants, Maybe?
34 minutes ago
5 comments:
"Smoking is the biggest preventable cause of death in England, causing over 80,000 premature deaths in England each year."
Such quotes always make me think of a cartoon I once saw, showing two decrepit old men sitting in wheelchairs, with one saying to the other "If I hadn't given up smoking, drinking and sex, I'd have missed out on all this".
Today program famous for that tactic.
Starts by "Research suggests" without any indication of the bias of any research organisation..
"Crisis is imminent".. or "crisis could be averted if.."
"Why isn't the government doing more?"
Even if the 'more' is so ridiculously expensive that it could never be efficient.Remember when they were trying to get some hapless minister {Buyers?} to promise that there would never be another rail death.. No attempt to compare road or air / sea deaths to rail.
"The answer must surely be more public spending, minister?"
If the answer is 'more public spending' then the Today program is asking the question.
Then when the minister flounders about and refuses to commit another few billion the 9am news headline ..
"The minister for transport has admitted on this program that there may be many more deaths on the railways as the government refuses to increase spending on safety measures.."
B, exactly. Smoking is bad for your physical health but good for your mental health.
BQ, that's a good template as well, but ends up with govt spokesman saying "No". The fakecharity template is used when the govt has already made a decision and is scratting around for 'evidence' to justify it.
Do you smoke, old son?
JH, yes of course.
Post a Comment