Saturday 18 April 2020

When is climate change not climate change?

From Eco Watch:

Global heating from the climate crisis is rapidly melting glaciers, revealing treasures underneath the ice from long ago. Retreating ice in Norway recently revealed a lost Viking mountain pass strewn with artifacts, according to a new study in the journal Antiquity.

The first discovery was an 1,800 year-old shirt, which spurred researchers to find what else was strewn around near the Lendbreen ice patch outside the alpine village of Lom, Norway. That led to an exploration that uncovered artifacts dating back to the late Roman Iron Age all the way to the Viking Age and the medieval period, as Scientific American reported.

When the researchers traipsed into the abandoned mountain pass that is rapidly melting due to warmer global temperatures, they found broken sleds, tools and other elements of daily life dating back nearly 2,000 years, as National Geographic reported...

They found nearly 1,000 artifacts that run the gamut from 300 to 1500 AD, with the mountain pass falling out of use after the Black Death in the medieval period. The researchers used carbon dating to pinpoint when each finding is from. The bulk of what they collected comes from the period around 1000 AD at the height of the Viking era when trade and mobility in the region peaked, according to The Guardian.

"A lost mountain pass melting out of the ice is a dream discovery for us glacial archaeologists," said Pilø in a statement, as CNN reported. "In such passes, past travelers left behind lots of artifacts, frozen in time by the ice..."


"Oh no", thinks the unsuspecting reader, "we're all going to drown".

Or are we?

The finds actually remind us that there was a Roman Warm Period and a Mediæval Warm Period (referred to here as 'the Viking era'), when the pass was relatively ice-free and in regular use. They didn't magically drop stuff under the ice, they dropped stuff and the ice then formed and covered it. Which is why the oldest finds are from the RWP and most are from the MWP:

The first discovery was an 1,800 year-old shirt... That led to an exploration that uncovered artifacts dating back to the late Roman Iron Age...

The bulk of what they collected comes from the period around 1000 AD at the height of the Viking era when trade and mobility in the region peaked... with the mountain pass falling out of use after the Black Death in the medieval period.


Now we are in the Modern Warm Period (they seem to come along every thousand years or so) and the ice has retreated to where it was during the earlier warm periods. The Black Death happened around the same time as (and was possibly caused by) the end of the MWP and the onset of the Little Ice Age. But it was the LIA that put an end to the use of this mountain pass, not the Black Death. There are plenty of e.g. Roman roads/routes that have been constantly in use for thousands of years, uninterrupted by the Black Death.

H/t Ben Pile

6 comments:

DAD said...

So if it was as warm (or warmer) then than today and nobody drown with sea levels rising by 100mm, 100cm 1m 10m (take your pick from the various predictions) what is the worry today?

To me, this find proves the the "climate emergency" is a hoax.

Shiney said...

And as far as I am aware the Vikings didn't burn much fossil fuel, so the warming wasn't 'man-made' or because of 'industrialisation'.

Mark Wadsworth said...

D, that is why the Alarmists have spent the last 20 years trying to air brush the MWP out of history, or dismiss it as a local European thing, not a global thing.

An extreme example of this is here - allegedly, Greenland remained cold throughout the MWP.

This is completely at odds with the traditional view that the Vikings made the most of a few centuries of warmer weather and then abandoned Greenland when it got cold again. In real life, they have excavated villages from UNDER the permafrost. Vikings sure as heck didn't build villages UNDER the permafrost, did they?

Sh, yes, but what happened back then was "natural climate change" and thus completely harmless, compared to man-made climate change, which is going to be very nasty. Lolz.

Bayard said...

I like the way they keep a straight face and keep carrying on just as if they haven't just contradicted themselves, or perhaps they didn't notice, too wrapped up in their belief system.

Mark Wadsworth said...

B, yes. People can think what they like, but if they have to constantly contradict themselves to support the basic premise, then that basic premise must be wrong (see also Home-Owner-Ism).

Bruce David said...

Hello everyone..Welcome to my free masterclass strategy where i teach experience and inexperience traders the secret behind a successful trade.And how to be profitable in trading I will also teach you how to make a profit of $12,000 USD weekly and how to get back all your lost funds feel free to email me on( brucedavid004@gmail.com ) or whataspp number is +22999290178  



























Hello everyone..Welcome to my free masterclass strategy where i teach experience and inexperience traders the secret behind a successful trade.And how to be profitable in trading I will also teach you how to make a profit of $12,000 USD weekly and how to get back all your lost funds feel free to email me on( brucedavid004@gmail.com ) or whataspp number is +22999290178