Friday 15 October 2010

Private Equity Fun

From The Evening Standard:

One of London's biggest bus companies today buckled under the weight of its own debt and collapsed into administration only to be bought immediately by its one-time owner Stagecoach.

The acquisition of the East London Bus Group marks Stagecoach's return to the London bus market. It sold the operator of the Selkent, Thameside and East London bus brands to Australian bank Macquarie for £263 million four years ago, only to buy it from the adminstrator KPMG today for £52.8 million...

Explaining Stagecoach's decision to sell the business to Macquarie in the first place, finance director Martin Griffiths said today: “If someone gives you more than a business is worth, you would sell. At the time, Macquarie offered us a price that we thought was great value for our shareholders. We were running it profitably at the time, and expect to do so again. It's a good opportunity for us to return.”


Yippee! Our heroes, people who owned and ran a decent business, made a cool £200 million out of some foreign investment bank smart arses. What's not to like? The article continues:

Candover, once a leading light in the buyout industry, is closing down its £2.5 billion flagship fund after running out of money on deals including gambling group Gala Coral, on which it wrote off millions alongside fellow players Cinven* and Permira last year.

Other high-profile private equity deals of woe include Apax's £750 million stake in magazine group Emap, which it wrote down to zero last year, and Fitness First, the gym chain that reported a £242 million loss on last year after owner BC Partners** paid off a £642 million interest payment on its loans.


* See also this tale of woe.

** See also this tale of woe.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

This lot probably borrow at around 5% (deals struck few years back). Now, if either bank wants 7% (due to basel III rules, capital more expensive), or BoE raise rate to 1.5%, there will be more fun to come.

Steven_L said...

A guess the teams of people down Canary wharf that sell PE loans are kind of like a scaled up 'Yes Car Credit' really.

...Well Mr Moneybags, you'll be pleased to know we've approved you for a loan of £367 million, for that we can get you on a small pharaceutical firm, a large retailer or a medium sized bus company, which will it be?

Mark Wadsworth said...

Anon, it's going to be years of fun.

The whole 'private equity' was a pyramid scheme based on the most unrealistic of expectations, the narrowest of margins and the highest leverage. Every time net profits of the acquired businesses fall 1% below target; or interest rates tick up by 10 bps; or bonds fall due for repayment there'll be another dozen stories like these.

SL, for that price you could snap up a tip top London estate agency (see final link!).

Bayard said...

Too late, it's no longer an estate agency, it's now a "real estate broker". (I've often wondered what estate there is that isn't real - imaginary estate? unreal estate? Come to think of it, given today's property prices, "unreal estate broker" would probably be closer to the mark, though "secondhand house dealer" would be more accurate overall.)

lilith said...

Or "Used house dealer"....

Mark Wadsworth said...

B, "real estate" is an antiquated term, from the days when "real" and "royal" were interchangeable (cf. "real tennis").

English property law refers to freeholds as 'real property', leaseholds as 'chattels real', chattels as 'chattels' and other legal rights (like shares, copyrights) as 'choses in action'.

L, or indeed "a fleet of Minis and some desks".